Reb Chaim
Unorthodox: The Scandalous Rejection of My Hasidic RootsReb Chaim is a famous kabbalist from Israel whose brief audience with the narrator becomes an important interpretive thread in her story. When she is six months pregnant, he predicts that the birth of her son will expose a secret surrounding her origins and urges her to watch for the number nine. She doubts his powers, yet later remembers his words when a serious car accident occurs at midnight on 09/09/09, shortly before she intends to leave her past behind.
Identity and Context
Reb Chaim comes from Yerushalayim and visits the United States a few times each year. His reputation as a kabbalist draws people who make considerable efforts to secure an audience with him. The narrator has little personal desire to meet him: she is skeptical of mysticism and has been questioning her belief in God. She is also uneasy around people who claim to see everything, unsure whether she wants to be seen so completely.
The audience is arranged through Eli’s friend because of the narrator’s pregnancy. By the time she is admitted, it is two in the morning. Reb Chaim’s wife sits in the room’s corner so that the narrator and Reb Chaim will not be alone together, in keeping with the community’s rules of gender separation. The circumstances place his reputed insight within a tightly observed religious setting: even a private consultation must accommodate communal boundaries.
The Audience and Its Predictions
Reb Chaim asks the narrator to write down her birthday, then spends several minutes making calculations on paper. He asks where her parents are and why they are not with her. He says she is not an orphan, but that her parents are nevertheless missing. The narrator briefly explains her circumstances; the account does not provide further detail about what she tells him.
He then announces, “There is a secret surrounding your birth,” and declares that the blood ties are not blood. In his prediction, the birth of her child will unravel the secret, bring the truth to light, and allow her to come to know herself through her son. The statement makes the coming birth more than a family milestone in his reading: it is presented as the means by which the narrator will learn something fundamental about her own identity. The evidence here records his claim, not an independent confirmation of what he knows or how he reached it.
Reb Chaim asks what the narrator plans to name the baby and approves her choice. He tells her that the child will change her life in ways she cannot yet understand, and that her path is already mapped even when events seem meaningless. He also calls her a very old soul and says that everything in her life is laden with meaning. These assertions contrast sharply with her private response. Though she nods earnestly, she thinks it is ridiculous that a man who has never met her could know what she is really like.
The Number Nine
Before the narrator leaves, Reb Chaim singles out the number nine as especially important and tells her not to ignore the signs. The warning remains distinct in her memory. Later, reflecting on the car accident that occurs as midnight changes the date to 09/09/09, she recalls his words and identifies nine with death and rebirth, endings and beginnings. She considers whether the accident, arriving only days before she plans to leave her past behind, might be a sign meant to stop her.
That connection belongs to the narrator’s retrospective interpretation; it does not establish that Reb Chaim foresaw the accident or that his prediction determines what follows. Its force lies in the way an earlier pronouncement becomes newly charged after an event she cannot readily explain. The number he asked her to remember gives her a language for the accident’s timing and for the sense that her life has divided into a before and an after.
Narrative Significance
Reb Chaim’s encounter with the narrator holds skepticism and the desire for meaning in unresolved tension. She enters the audience doubtful of mysticism and leaves unconvinced that the kabbalist can know her. Yet his statements about her birth, her son, and nine persist as points of reference when later events prompt her to reconsider their significance. The narrative preserves both positions: his confident predictions and her distrust of them.
His role is consequently limited but consequential. He does not explain the narrator’s family history in the encounter, and the account does not show him verifying the secret he announces. Instead, he gives shape to questions that remain open at the time: what her origins conceal, what motherhood may reveal, and whether apparent coincidences carry meaning. The later date of the accident makes his warning memorable without resolving whether it was foresight, coincidence, or a meaning the narrator recognizes only afterward.